TBD logo
Stephanie

Hey! I’m Stephanie, I’m a Registered Dietician. I'm passionate about making supplement trends easy to understand

Gummies vs. Powders:
Which Is Best For Your Health?

Quick Take: If you want maximal nutrition, reliable dosing, and better gut support for less money, choose a greens powder. Gummies are tasty and convenient, but most of what you’re chewing isn’t greens.

Why I Did This Research

When it comes to green supplements, the good news is that there are numerous options for you to try, from gummies to green powders, capsules, and more. The not-so-good news is that, as a dietitian, I know not every format is created equally in terms of nutritional value.

To help you make sense of these supplements and determine which format best aligns with your health goals, I decided to compare gummies and greens powders side-by-side. While both offer their own benefits, follow along to find out why greens powders remain the clear winner in my book!

Why I Think Greens Powders Are Better Than Gummies

GREENS POWDERS
Live it Up

GUMMIES
Grüns

Delicious Drink
Delicious Drink
Delicious Snack
Delicious Snack
Convenient

One scoop

One scoop
Convenient

8 gummies

8 gummies
Real Greens, No Fillers

Superfoods like leafy greens, cereal grasses, algae

Superfoods like leafy greens, cereal grasses, algae
Roughly 50% pectin, water, and sugar
Contains Fillers

Roughly 50% pectin, water, and sugar

No added sugar, naturally sweetened
No Added Sugar

No added sugar, naturally sweetened

Added sugar
Added Sugar
Natural vitamins and minerals from whole foods, concentrated superfoods (leafy greens, crucifers, algae) and enzymes for nutrient absorption
Natural Energy

Natural vitamins and minerals from whole foods

Synthetic vitamins and minerals aren’t as bioavailable, 40–60% of serving is gummy base, not greens, possible sugar spike (and crash)
Synthetic Energy

Synthetic vitamins and minerals aren’t as bioavailable

Probiotics, digestive enzymes, dietary fiber with prebiotics
Comprehensive Gut Support

Probiotics, digestive enzymes, dietary fiber with prebiotics

High prebiotic fibermay cause digestive upset*

Limited Gut Support

High prebiotic fiber
may cause digestive upset*


$1.33 per serving
Affordable

$1.33 per serving

~50% more expensive$1.89 per serving
Pricey

~50% more expensive
$1.89 per serving

What’s the Difference? Greens Powders vs. Gummies

Here’s my deep dive into the research behind these two types of green supplements and their key differences.

Powders Are More Nutrient Dense

Powders are more than 90% greens:

Greens powders are often packed with high concentrations of vitamins, minerals, and superfoods that align with daily recommended doses, offering more greens per serving than gummies. Many green powders also contain naturally derived vitamins and minerals.

Gummies are 50-70% made up of fillers:

In comparison, greens gummies typically contain fillers like pectin or gelatin and water that occupy a lot of valuable space in the formula, leaving little room for the nutritious ingredients you really want. Plus, many gummies use synthetic nutrients rather than those derived from whole foods.

Gummies Need Fillers to Keep Their Form

The best greens powders often contain all-natural, nutritious, whole foods with little to no additives or fillers.

‍‍Meanwhile, gummies may include fillers, gelling agents, preservatives, artificial colors, and added sugars (depending on the brand). The gel-forming compounds are necessary to give the gummies their chewy texture, while the sugars and sweeteners ensure the sweet taste expected from gummy bears.

Green Powders Better Support Energy, Digestion, and Overall Health

Greens powders are packed with real superfoods and often include probiotics and digestive enzymes—giving your body more nutrition per serving and directly supporting digestion, nutrient absorption, and steady energy.

Gummies, by contrast, fill much of their serving with sugar and gel bases and often lack gut-supporting actives. They also lose nutrient integrity during manufacturing, making their doses less reliable for consistent health benefits.

Gummy Sweeteners Can Disrupt Your Gut

Greens powders typically have no added sugar, as they use natural sweeteners (like monk fruit or stevia) to enhance their flavors.

‍‍These candy-like supplements often contain added sugar (or sweeteners) to achieve their sweet taste. Unfortunately, these sugars can have a negative impact on your gut microbiome and oral health. Even sugar-free gummies that use natural sweeteners may cause indigestion.

Powders Are Easier to Fit Into Your Routine & Personalize

Greens powders are flexible and versatile, allowing you to personalize the way you consume them. For instance, you can mix them into water, smoothies, juice, and yogurt, or even create your own recipes with them.

Gummies definitely get points in the convenience department, as they provide a fun and easy way to get nutrients on the go. That said, you can’t mix up how you consume them.

Why Greens Powders Take the Crown

When it comes to green gummies, the convenience factor is a definite perk, but if you stack them up side-by-side, it’s a no-brainer IMO which one is the winner.

  • More nutrition per serving: Fewer fillers = more room for real greens and supportive actives.
  • Better for overall health & energy: Packed with concentrated superfoods (leafy greens, cereal grasses, algae).
    Includes enzymes for nutrient absorption.
  • Better gut support: Probiotics + enzymes are common in powders, rare in gummies.
  • Stable & reliable: Less heat/moisture stress in processing; doses stay closer to what’s on the label.
  • Lower sugar: Often 0g added sugar; easier on teeth and microbiome.
  • Better value: Powders can undercut gummies on price per effective serving.

My go-to greens powder is Live it Up Super Greens. The formula contains natural, organic ingredients, such as leafy greens, cruciferous vegetables, and cereal grasses, as well as vitamins and minerals derived from whole foods. It’s naturally sweetened with monk fruit extract and comes in two delicious, refreshing flavors.

Live it Up: Super Greens

Live it Up: Super Greens
EXCLUSIVE OFFER
Save with code: TODAY10

What I love:

  • Top variety of health benefits
  • Digestion, gut health, bloating, energy, immune support, healthy aging
  • Research-backed
  • Forbes' recommendation
  • Third-party tested
  • Made with organic vegetables
  • Clean and transparent ingredients
  • All-natural, nothing synthetic
  • Probiotics and digestive enzymes
  • Sugar free
  • No stevia or artificial sweeteners
  • The best tasting greens powder
  • Non-GMO, vegan, gluten-free
  • Best tasting (fresh and natural)
  • Premium product without premium pricing
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Free shipping

What could be better:

  • Not the cheapest option
  • Thin powder
  • Only available online

Greens Powders vs. Gummies: Recap

Live it Up: Super Greens

Grüns Gummies

Convenient to Consume
Variety of Superfoods
Reliable Nutrients
Contains Probiotics

Dietary fiber
Probiotics
Digestives enzymes

Dietary fiber with inulin

Sweeteners

Monk fruit extract

8g cane sugar (low sugar option)
Allulose and Reb M
(sugar-free option)

Only Natural Ingredients
No Fillers
Vegan and Non-GMO
GMP-Certified andThird-Party Tested
Price per Serving With Subscription
$1.33
$1.89
SEE OFFER
EXCLUSIVE OFFER
Save with code: TODAY10